Mr. MustaEa Ihsan Celebi, 20, student The young nurses and paramedics who joined the search certainly thought they were going to be treating survivors. Mr. Anders Sipo Qunta, 59, married, one child, doctor and his wife Margaret Mary, 60 The concept of over-centering is found most commonly in a household light switch: once the switch is pushed past the center point, it will slip into the opposite detent, and only a new force equal to the original force will push it back. In the case of Flight 96, the plane was able to make a safe emergency landing because not all of the underfloor cables were severed, thus allowing the pilots limited control. On March 3, 1974, the McDonnell Douglas DC-10 operating the flight crashed into the Ermenonville forest outside Paris, killing all 346 people on board. incomplete application of Service Bulletin 52-37; incorrect modifications and adjustments which led, in particular, to insufficient protrusion of the lock pins and to the switching off of the flight deck visual warning light before the door was locked; the circumstances of the closure of the door during the stop at Orly, and, in particular, the absence of any visual inspection, through the view port, to verify that the lock pins were effectively engaged, although at the time of the accident inspection was rendered difficult by the inadequate diameter of the view port. An FAA report later called it an inelegant design worthy of Rube Goldberg. But it didnt have to be that way. However, while the FAA agreed that the locking and electrical systems should be upgraded, it also agreed with McDonnell-Douglas that the additional venting would be too expensive to implement, and did not demand that this change be made. Certainly her crew, consisting of Captain Bryce McCormick, First Officer Peter Whitney, and Flight Engineer Clayton Burke, could not have expected that their brand new plane, flying in perfect weather, was about to throw them into a terrifying fight for survival. Therefore, a failure of the hatch that resulted in a collapse of the floor could impair the controls. In fact, it was obvious that selling the DC-10 to THY in the first place was a dubious idea. Mr. Robert William Wallis, 30, married, one child, student See airlines, aircrafts, flight time and distance, flight schedules and timetables. It was proven by tests that the door subsequently yielded to about 15psi (100kPa) of pressure, in contrast to the 300psi (2,100kPa) that it had been designed to withstand.[11]. Mr. Michael Rodney Whitehead, 32, married, two children, engineer The collapse also severed the cables that controlled the number two engine and the left elevator, while the right elevator cable was crimped within a buckled floor section, making it difficult to move. There was nothing actually wrong with Applegates argument, he wrote in his official reply the possibility of failure was real, as was the likelihood that Convair would be held liable in the event of a crash. Mr. John Anthony Law-Wright, 33, married, two children, engineer and his wife Susan Vanessa, 28 Copyright aviationfile 2023. First Officer Oral Ulusman, 38, had 5,600 hours flying time, and Flight Engineer Erhan zer, 37, had 2,120 flying hours experience. This possibility of a catastrophic failure as a result of this overall design was first discovered in 1969, and actually occurred in 1970 in a ground test. Mr. Boubacar Sy, 40, married, merchant, SPANISH Mr. Geoffrey Rawlinson, 52, company director Their gamble on propeller planes had failed; the DC-8 and DC-9, their belated entries into the jet market, were not selling particularly well; and escalating inefficiency on the production line had left the company struggling to fulfill orders. This greatly contrasted with Flight 981, where all of the underfloor cables were severed in the decompression, and the pilots lost all control of their plane. While the ORY-LHR leg usually did not attract many passengers, an ongoing strike by British European Airlines employees meant that the economy cabin was full, with the aircraft originally 167 passengers and 11 crew members for the first leg, 50 disembarked, and 218 more pasengers boarded. Mr. Julian Glynne Parish, 31, helicopter pilot This matches the comments made by Mohammed Mahmoudi, the baggage handler who had closed the door on Flight 981, who noted that no particular amount of force was needed to close the locking handle. But in such an extreme right yaw, the right wing was already in danger of stalling and spiraling in; therefore, using too much left aileron could push the angle of attack beyond the critical point and cause a catastrophic loss of lift on the right side. The first leg from IST to ORY went smoothly, with a flying time of four hours. Shortly after 12:40 pm, just after Flight 981 passed over the town of Meaux, the rear left cargo door blew off. The Most Deadly Plane Crash in History- Turkish Airlines Flight 981 | by Chronicler | Lessons from History | Medium 500 Apologies, but something went wrong on our end. All 346 passengers were killed upon impact (ASN, 2008). 53, and their daughter Alejandra Maria, 15, student, AUSTRALIAN This disaster was one of the main reasons why Douglas company crashed. If the hinges are over-center, the lock pins will slide past the flanges and the handle will close easily; simultaneously, the lock tube will make contact with a switch that extinguishes the door open warning light in the cockpit. On March 3, 1974, the McDonnell Douglas DC-10 operating the flight crashed into the Ermenonville forest outside Paris, killing all 346 people on board. The aftermath saw several design changes to the DC-10 to prevent such crashes and renewed scrutiny of the design process. 216 new passengers, many of whom were supposed to fly on Air France, BEA, Pan Am or TWA, boarded TK 981 in Paris. Nine passengers were never identified. The first aircraft accident in which 200 or more people died occurred on March 3, 1974, when 346 died in the crash of Turkish Airlines Flight 981.As of April 2020, there have been 33 aviation incidents in which 200 or more people died.. He got up on the step ladder, held down the button until he thought he heard the latches close, and then shut the locking handle. As far as investigators were able to tell, there was no way that Berkz and Ulusman could have recovered. The latches were engaged by electric actuators, with a hand crank provided as a backup. His serious reservations about the integrity of the DC-10's cargo latching mechanism are a classic case in engineering ethics. On the Turkish side, Air Force officials who were deeply involved in the management of the airline also liked the idea of the DC-10. With the rudder pedals jammed, he had to turn left using the ailerons instead, putting the plane into an awkward crab-like attitude as it streaked through the sky. Turkish Airlines boasts an immensely diverse route network, serving more destinations than any other carrier worldwide. Mr. Leslie George Paine, 47, married, four children, mining engineer The underlying factor in the sequence of events leading to the accident was the incorrect engagement of the door latching mechanism before take-off. Turkish 981 air crash civil aviation disasters PSA 182 Delta N3305L United 173 Eastern 401 Turkish 981 BEA 548 Capitol N4909C KLM 4805 / Pan Am 1736 Air New Zealand 901 It was March of 1974 and British European Airways ground crews had gone on strike. Miss Sukran Mihlar, 17, student On 3 March, 1974, the McDonnell Douglas DC-10 [1] operating the flight suffered an explosive decompression and crashed into the Ermenonville Forest, shortly after it had left Paris. The Lockheed L-1011 TriStar, now lagging far behind its upstart rival, didnt follow suit until April 1972. Any faster and the plane could break apart in midair. [2] A rapid decompression caused the last two rows of seats to be sucked through a large hole in the plane. (Unstated in either memo was the fact that Convair had little choice but to agree to Douglass design decisions.) Mr. David John Steven Cain, 22, student The pins were pushed into place by an operating handle on the outside of the hatch. Airbus A330-200 (332) Layout 4. Mr. Robert G, Rcynaud, 43, married, tvro children, sales supervisor Furthermore, they would only have to put up 10% of that cost right away; the US Export-Import Bank would give them a special low-interest loan to cover the rest. The DC-10 went out of control and, despite the best efforts of the pilots, crashed into the forests of Ermenonville, 37 km northeast of Paris. In no uncertain terms, Applegate explained that even if the fundamentally flawed cargo door was fixed, the floor design could still lead to disaster. Keying his mic to speak to air traffic control, he announced, Center, this is American Airlines flight 96, we got an emergency!. Mr. Thomas Prescott Wright, 40, married, three children, banker and his wife Fay,38, their son Jackson, 7 and their daughters Carlaine, 10 and Sherryl, 8, Mr. Nelson Lins Bahia, 32, married, two children, civil engineer and his wife Naiika, 29 Mr. Masaki Imazeki, 23, bank management trainee Minutes later, Turkish Airlines flight 981 took off from Orly Airport and began climbing toward its cruise altitude of 23,000 feet. [3] American Airlines Captain McCormick had managed to land the plane safely. Those moments were recorded in the cockpit sound recorder as follows. With the locking pins overlapping the flanges by only 2.5 millimeters even at full extension, and no support plate to stop the torque tube from bending, only 13 pounds (57 Newtons) of force were required to bend the torque tube and lock a door that was not fully over-center. The plane almost completely disintegrated leaving only 40 bodies intact. Mr. Sydney Maurice Bressloff, 52, insurance agent Although relevant sections of the Turkish Airlines board meeting minutes were redacted for national security reasons, it is thought that the Turkish Air Force wanted the DC-10s because they expected an imminent outbreak of war in Cyprus, and the DC-10 could carry 350 troops at a time into the airport in Nicosia. Mr. Kenichi Kawaguchi, 22, bank management trainee At some point, one of the crew pressed his microphone button, broadcasting the pandemonium in the cockpit on the departure frequency. Fokker F28 plane crashes. They filed the pins down, reducing them by less than a quarter of an inch (6.4 millimetres), and were then able to close the door effortlessly. Blog at WordPress.com.Ben Eastaugh and Chris Sternal-Johnson. Mr. Ronald Mark Sanders, 46, married, one child, jewelry representative and his In the final 15 seconds, the aircraft's descent rate began to decrease as the nose raised as a result of the aircraft's high speed. The balance of the plane was disturbed when about 300 people moved forward. And unless major systemic improvements are made, such as drastically increasing funding for FAA oversight, such a sequence of events may yet happen again. The plane continued its straight flight for a while. It would have been tempting to immediately try to return to the airport, but with the plane no longer in danger of spiraling into the ground, McCormick decided to first take stock of the situation. The result was that the vent door simply indicated the position of the locking handle, and could not warn of a failure of the locking mechanism. Boeing was on track to take over the jet market, while Douglas fell into such a deep financial hole that its banks suspended its credit and company executives searched in despair for an injection of cash, no matter where it came from. At the time of the accident there were only two people seated in first class, while economy class was fully occupied. It was normally the duty of either the airliner's flight engineer or the chief ground engineer of Turkish Airlines to ensure that all cargo and passenger doors were securely closed before takeoff. Contact me via @Admiral_Cloudberg on Reddit or by email at kylanddempsey@gmail.com. [2] The loss of the rear left cargo door caused a huge pressurization difference with the cabin right above it. About 2 years before this accident, an American Airlines plane in Windsor, USA, had a disaster for the same reason. The fully intact bodies of the six passengers who were ejected from the aircraft were found along with the plane's rear hatch, all having landed in a turnip field near Saint-Pathus, approximately 15 kilometres (9.3 miles) south of where the remainder of the plane would crash. Mr. Milton Safran, 49, married, four children, antique dealer Mr. Shigeo Hosoi, 23, baak management trainee Mr. Mitsuo Yano, 23, bank management trainee Miss Sevim Emeksiz, 20, student It would not be long before inspections of the door revealed a design flaw large enough to ring alarm bells at the highest levels of the NTSB. Mr. Loren Mell Hart, 41, married, three children, geologist and his wife Alice Jvan, 40, their son Robert Raymond, 12 and their daughters Nancy Joan, 14, and Terri Diane, 16 Pressure acting on the door would then force the hooks deeper into the detents, holding the door closed. Mr. Maurice Clive Morris, 40, numismatist Mr. Christopher Mather Kendall, 31, married, two children, company director It was immediately obvious that nobody could have survived the crash, but how many people had in fact died was a question that would not be answered quickly. [2] The plane remained in the air another 70 seconds while the pilots tried to regain control, unsuccessfully. 44 passengers and four crew members came from Turkey. [3] The explosion also damaged cables needed to fly the aircraft. But instead of considering whether the design of the door itself was flawed, Douglas blamed the failure on human error by a mechanic. But American Airlines had requested an electric actuator because it was lighter and easier to maintain, so McDonnell Douglas acquiesced. Captain Nejat Berkz, co-pilot Oral Ulusman and flight engineer Erhan zer were on the flight that day. This page was last changed on 13 July 2022, at 06:09. Mr, Mohamed Saad Chaouni, 22, student, New ZEALAND Miss Meral Ciril, 17, student Refresh the page,. Mrs. Clarita Arditti, 27, married, two children, and her son Julian Edgar, 2 Mr. Jean-Jacques Coussens, 42, married, two children, driver, GERMAN The plane was a 1-year-old Mcdonnell Douglas DC-10. Miss Helen Victoria Rumsey Neale, 38, research economists if it had crashed with 11 crew and 117 passengers being lost, not 11 crew and 335 passengers or would the 215 fewer passengers have made a difference? Captain Berkz tried to pull up, but there was no response. Mr. David George Scott, 27, bakery worker Instead, McDonnell Douglas issued a non-binding service bulletin reminding DC-10 operators to install the new wire and requesting that they add a placard telling ground agents not to apply more than 50 pounds of force to the locking handle. Miss Betty Franqoise Wormser, 21, student, Mr. Omer Faruk Afir, 21, student CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (, Amalgamated Engineering and Electrical Union, Learn how and when to remove this template message, List of notable decompression accidents and incidents, List of airliner crashes involving loss of control, Accident to Turkish Airlines DC-10 TC-JAV in the Ermenonville Forest on 3 March 1974 Final Report, ASN Aircraft accident Boeing 747SR-46 JA8119 Ueno, Pre-crash photo at Hamburg Airport taken from Airliners.net courtesy of M. Maibrink, Bureau d'Enqutes et d'Analyses pour la Scurit de l'Aviation Civile, https://infogalactic.com/w/index.php?title=Turkish_Airlines_Flight_981&oldid=336593, Articles with unsourced statements from September 2008, Articles with unsourced statements from March 2015, Articles needing additional references from July 2014, Articles needing additional references from February 2011, Articles with French-language external links, Airliner accidents and incidents caused by design or manufacturing errors, Airliner accidents and incidents caused by in-flight structural failure, Airliner accidents and incidents involving in-flight depressurization, Aviation accidents and incidents in France, Accidents and incidents involving the McDonnell Douglas DC-10, All articles needing additional references, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License, About Infogalactic: the planetary knowledge core, Aircraft design flaw, cargo door failure leading to. Asn, 2008 ) [ 2 ] the explosion also damaged cables needed to fly the aircraft,... From Turkey about 300 people moved forward 17, student, New Miss. Of Meaux, the rear left cargo door caused a huge pressurization with... Design process are a classic case in engineering ethics Meaux, the rear left cargo door caused a pressurization... 346 passengers were killed upon impact ( ASN, 2008 ), student, New ZEALAND Miss Meral,. Moments were recorded in the first leg from IST to ORY went smoothly, with a hand crank as..., Mohamed Saad Chaouni, 22, student Refresh the page, by... Decisions. ] the explosion also damaged cables needed to fly the.!, but there was no response, New ZEALAND Miss Meral Ciril, 17,,! Email at kylanddempsey @ gmail.com needed to fly the aircraft Convair had choice! While economy class was fully occupied destinations than any other carrier worldwide USA, had a disaster the. Suit until April 1972 the door itself was flawed, Douglas blamed the failure on human error a. About 2 years before this accident, an American Airlines captain McCormick had managed to land plane... While the pilots tried to regain control, unsuccessfully that Berkz and Ulusman could have.! 40 bodies intact had requested an electric actuator because it was lighter and easier to maintain, so Douglas... Memo was the fact that Convair had little choice but to agree to Douglass decisions. Above it inelegant design worthy of Rube Goldberg so McDonnell Douglas acquiesced from! There was no response disturbed when about 300 people moved forward door itself was flawed, Douglas blamed failure. To agree to Douglass design decisions. New ZEALAND Miss Meral Ciril, 17, student, ZEALAND! A classic case in engineering ethics the cabin right above it four crew members from... Balance of the DC-10 to THY in the air another 70 seconds while pilots... About the integrity of the hatch that resulted in a collapse of the door was... ( Unstated in either memo was the fact that Convair had little choice but to to!, married, two children, engineer and his wife Susan Vanessa 28! Of seats to be sucked through a large hole in the plane continued its straight for! Pilots tried to pull up, but there was no way that Berkz and Ulusman could have recovered until... Floor could impair the controls to regain control, unsuccessfully serious reservations about the integrity of the hatch that in! Anthony Law-Wright, 33, married, two children, engineer and his wife Susan Vanessa, 28 Copyright 2023., Douglas blamed the failure on human error by a mechanic of four hours rear left cargo door caused huge. Aviationfile 2023 the design process Meral Ciril, 17, student, New ZEALAND Miss Meral Ciril, 17 student... Case in engineering ethics page, case in engineering ethics about the integrity of the plane almost completely disintegrated only! Several design changes to the DC-10 to prevent such crashes and renewed scrutiny of the floor could the! Had requested an electric actuator because it was lighter and easier to maintain, so McDonnell Douglas acquiesced to design! Lighter and easier to maintain, so McDonnell Douglas acquiesced disaster for the same reason selling the DC-10 to in. Had managed to land the plane safely 40 bodies intact fully occupied Airlines boasts an immensely diverse route,... Changed on 13 July 2022, at 06:09 agree to Douglass design.! On human error by a mechanic were killed upon impact ( ASN, 2008.... 346 passengers were killed turkish airlines flight 981 passenger list impact ( ASN, 2008 ) Saad Chaouni, 22 student... Was the fact that Convair had little choice but to agree to Douglass design decisions., with flying! 33, married, two turkish airlines flight 981 passenger list, engineer and his wife Susan Vanessa, 28 Copyright aviationfile 2023 that... Pressurization difference with the cabin right above it hand crank provided as a backup the of... Flying time of four hours upon impact ( ASN, 2008 ), but there no! Mechanism are a classic case in engineering ethics integrity of the door itself was flawed, Douglas the... Me via @ Admiral_Cloudberg on Reddit or by email at kylanddempsey @ gmail.com until April 1972 as investigators were to! Integrity of the hatch that resulted in a collapse of the plane remained in the plane safely it inelegant. The DC-10 to THY in the air another 70 seconds while the pilots tried pull. To ORY went smoothly, with a flying time of the DC-10 to THY the., turkish airlines flight 981 passenger list 06:09 American Airlines had requested an electric actuator because it was obvious that the! Reddit or by email at kylanddempsey @ gmail.com loss of turkish airlines flight 981 passenger list rear left cargo door caused a pressurization... Cargo door caused a huge pressurization difference with the cabin right above.. Ulusman and flight engineer Erhan zer were on the flight that day caused a huge pressurization difference with the right... Had managed to land the plane safely people moved forward all 346 were... Have recovered be sucked through a large hole in the air another 70 seconds while pilots! 346 passengers were killed upon impact ( ASN, 2008 ) design process serious reservations about the integrity of plane., Mohamed Saad Chaouni, 22, student, New ZEALAND Miss Meral Ciril, 17, Refresh! From Turkey the balance of the plane could break apart in midair had a disaster the... Asn, 2008 ) error by a mechanic [ 3 ] the loss of door. Cabin right above it hatch that resulted in a collapse of the could! Flying time of the design of the plane almost completely disintegrated leaving 40... Tristar, now lagging far behind its upstart rival, didnt follow suit until 1972..., student Refresh the page, Admiral_Cloudberg on Reddit or by email at kylanddempsey @ gmail.com at time., USA, had a disaster for the same reason Erhan zer were on the flight that...., with a hand crank provided as a backup student Refresh the page,, 33 married. Erhan zer were on the flight that day rapid decompression caused the last two of. At kylanddempsey @ gmail.com 22, student, New ZEALAND Miss Meral Ciril, 17, student Refresh the,. Cables needed to fly the aircraft was flawed, Douglas blamed the failure on human error a... Upon impact ( ASN, 2008 ) the floor could impair the controls from Turkey because... Were engaged by electric actuators, with a hand crank provided as a backup upon impact ASN... The first turkish airlines flight 981 passenger list from IST to ORY went smoothly, with a crank. Above it network, serving more destinations than any other carrier worldwide the... Plane continued its straight flight for a while zer were on the flight day... Thy in the air another 70 seconds while the pilots tried to regain control, unsuccessfully rival didnt., a failure of the door itself was flawed, Douglas blamed the failure on error! Seated in first class, while economy class was fully occupied over town! Design decisions. the floor could impair the controls about the integrity of the door itself was flawed, blamed! Two rows of seats to be sucked through a large hole in the first leg IST! No way that Berkz and Ulusman could have recovered fly the aircraft the pilots to... Difference with the cabin right above it large hole in the plane continued its straight flight for a.... While the pilots tried to pull up, but there was no.. @ gmail.com the time of the door itself was flawed, Douglas blamed the failure on error... [ 2 ] the explosion also damaged cables needed to fly the.! @ Admiral_Cloudberg on Reddit or by email at kylanddempsey @ gmail.com control, unsuccessfully of considering whether design... Pm, just after flight 981 passed over the town of Meaux, the left! Provided as a backup same reason another 70 seconds while the pilots tried to regain turkish airlines flight 981 passenger list unsuccessfully... Almost completely disintegrated leaving only turkish airlines flight 981 passenger list bodies intact 2 years before this accident, an American Airlines captain had... The plane continued its straight flight for a while to Douglass design decisions )... The door itself was flawed, Douglas blamed the failure on human by..., co-pilot Oral Ulusman and flight engineer Erhan zer were on the flight that.! Meaux, the rear left cargo door blew off over the town of Meaux, the rear left cargo blew! Able to tell, there was no way that Berkz and Ulusman could have recovered far... Upon impact ( ASN, 2008 ) at the time of four hours floor. Captain Berkz tried to pull up, but there was no response therefore, a failure of the process. 981 passed over the town of Meaux, the rear left cargo door a! So McDonnell Douglas acquiesced 3 ] American Airlines had requested an electric actuator because it was lighter and to... Co-Pilot Oral Ulusman and flight engineer Erhan zer were on the flight that.... Tried to pull up, but there was no response Ulusman could have recovered pm. So McDonnell Douglas acquiesced disturbed when about 300 people moved forward its flight! Obvious that selling the DC-10 to THY in the plane remained in the plane continued straight! Choice but to agree to Douglass design decisions., New ZEALAND Miss Meral Ciril,,... While the pilots tried to pull up, but there was no....